HACKER Q&A
📣 roschdal

Why has Wikipedia become evil?


Wikipedia is actively deleting articles about new things because they are "not notable", censoring real articles and news, promoting their specific politics and in general not being the Wikipedia for the world and internet.


  👤 ben_w Accepted Answer ✓
I remember first hearing this complaint in… sometime between end of 2011 and end of 2013.

You'll have to be more specific to be able to claim this is actually about censorship and not notability and trustworthy sources.

Even printed national newspapers fall foul of the latter e.g.: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Not...

In part due to stuff like this: https://web.archive.org/web/20141207103758/https://www.thegu...


👤 fsflover
Without any links, this is just an empty accusation.

👤 armchairhacker
The world that Wikipedia was created in no longer exists. They can’t grow in the new world without changing. They don’t want to change, so they no longer grow.

Probably because the new world seems to be worse at open collaboration. For example, they worry that accepting new maintainers (without careful screening which ensures, deliberately or not, they won’t change the organization), they will accept ideologues and Jia Tans. Wikipedia already has a serious problem with these and dedicates lots of resources to finding and stopping them, it’s why they’re hesitant to accept new contributions; but opening the organization to change would very likely make it worse, because new changes have new exploits.

vlian2088 is also correct that they’ve already been captured by a specific group which has shaped it to their biases. From that group’s perspective, even some good changes are bad. But opening it could introduce more hard-to-reverse bias.

Personally, I think we should try to figure out a new model for a new Wikipedia that thrives in today’s world.


👤 vlian2088
every Internet community eventually gets taken over by those who spend more time online.

👤 Sia123
Also heard this complaint from my friends……

👤 beardyw
This has always been so in my experience. You can't just add any old thing, much as you would like to.